Evaluating Sustainable Feed Alternatives in Sparus aurata: How Alternative Proteins and Oils Maintain EPA+DHA Content and Improve Human Health Lipid Indices

Abstract

This study evaluated the effects of alternative feed formulations on the proximate composition and lipid quality of gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata) in a long-term feeding trial (May 2022–September 2023). Three isoenergetic and isoproteic diets were tested in replicate tanks: a fishmeal-based control (CTRL), a processed animal protein–based diet (PAP), and a diet including insect meal and microalgae oil (ALT). Diet pellet sizes were adapted to the fishes’ developmental stage. Proximate composition and fatty acid profiles were assessed in feed and in fish fillets, with 20 fish analyzed per dietary treatment. The human health lipid indices of the fillets were calculated. Virtual diets were reconstructed to estimate theoretical fatty acid intake across growth, based on feed composition and consumption. Partial least squares discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) revealed distinct clustering by diet. Fillets from all diets met European Food Safety Authority criteria for being high in omega-3 fatty acids, with some variation in EPA and DHA concentrations among formulations. The ALT diet showed a 15% higher EPA+DHA content and the greatest fish lipid quality (FLQ) values, even having the lowest polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) intake from feed, partly due to its elevated lauric acid (C12:0) content, which may contribute to rapid energy mobilization and omega-3 preservation. PAP-fed fish showed the most balanced PUFA/SFA and n6/n3 ratios. These findings demonstrate the viability of sustainable feed alternatives for maintaining nutritional quality in gilthead sea bream, supporting aquaculture sustainability without compromising nutritional value.