Goals, Effects and Challenges of the Financial Transaction Tax: A Comparative Law Study in France, Italy and Spain

Abstract

The Preamble of the Spanish Financial Transaction Tax Law establishes that “[t]he shaping of the tax follows the line taken by our neighbouring countries, including France and Italy, thus contributing to greater coordination of these taxes across Europe.” In this sense, the Spanish tax shows important similarities with those established in France and Italy in relation to the levy on the acquisition of certain shares and securities representing the capital of a company for consideration. Nev- ertheless, both the French and the Italian taxes apply to other

types of transactions, not covered by the Spanish Law, which is why it is necessary to carry out the corresponding compar- ative study. Furthermore, the effects that have arisen from the application of this kind of taxes to financial transactions mer- ited a proper analysis in order to determine if the main goals pursued by these taxes have been achieved in an efficient way. In any case, there are emerging tax challenges in financial mar- kets connected, on the one hand, to the use of crypto-assets and distributed ledger technology, and, on the other hand, to the implementation of artificial intelligence and machine learning and the fair taxation of these operations.